REVIEW DATE: 03 Oct 2007
Stop & Start Technology Makes A Lot Of Sense For Urban Drivers. Jonathan Crouch Tries It In Citroen's C3 1.4 16v
With Citroen's C3 Stop & Start, the main questions centre not around why you'd buy one but why you wouldn't want to. After all, the arguments for an automatic engine switch off in stop-start traffic are pretty straightforward.
With the 'Stop & Start' system, the engine is automatically turned off and is in 'standby mode' when the vehicle stops at traffic lights and in traffic jams. The engine instantly starts up again when the brake pedal is released, with the vehicle pulling away once the accelerator is pressed. This C3 is the first mass-produced car equipped with this innovative system and, for the time being, can only be ordered in 1.4-litre 16v petrol form with the semi-automatic 'SensoDrive' transmission, Citroen's electronically controlled manual gearbox.
In testing, Citroen reckon that the 'Stop & Start' system has reduced fuel consumption by 10% for city driving, 6% in a standard combined cycle and up to 15% in heavy traffic. All this sounds reasonable, as does the fact that CO2 emissions should be reduced by a similar proportion. You could also argue - and Citroen do - that widespread adoption of 'Stop & Start' technology would help to improve the quality of life in cities, since drivers and the urban environment would benefit from total silence during the many times vehicles are stopped.
With studies slowing that traffic in inner city areas can be stationary for up to 30% of the time, this C3 could offer even greater savings for urban drivers faced with the daily prospect of traffic lights, pedestrian crossings and congestion. The system stops the engine a split second before the car comes to a standstill, then restarts it again in just 400 milliseconds (twice as quickly as a traditional starter motor) the moment the driver takes their foot off the brake pedal and wants to accelerate away as normal.
The secret behind this technology is apparently a reversible alternator that acts as a standard alternator one minute (driven by the engine to charge the battery) but when required, also acts as a starter motor, driven by the battery to effortlessly restart the engine.
"With traffic in urban areas stationary for up to 30% of the time, 'Stop & Start' makes sense."
Since 'Stop & Start' is the kind of technology aimed at people who've one eye on fuel bills, you might have expected it to appear on a diesel-engined model first. It doubtless soon will but, for the time being, Citroen are looking for a publicity splash and the simple truth is that the savings that this system achieves allied to diesel power are nothing like as great.
Perhaps more significant is the fact that 'Stop & Start', like the 1.4-litre 16v petrol model itself, can't be ordered with a conventional manual gearbox, instead working as part of the semi-automatic SensoDrive paddle shift system. Since incorporating it means only a few changes to the software, Citroen are consequently able to offer the technology at little or no extra cost for C3 1.4 16v petrol customers. The rub will come when 'Stop & Start' gets rolled out to other engines, forcing buyers to stump up an extra £200-£300 for the questionable benefit of SensoDrive transmission. We're not great fans of this rather jerky system, although it should be pointed out that it does marginally improve fuel consumption and CO2 emissions.
Enough on 'Stop & Start', what about the 1.4-litre engine under the bonnet? Well, performance is brisk without risk of turning the front tyres into smouldering carcasses every time you tread on the righthand pedal. The C3 1.4 16v will accelerate to 60mph in 12.7 seconds before running on to a very respectable top speed of 111mph. The extra 11 lb/ft of low and mid range torque make the 16v unit feel a good deal gutsier than its 8v sibling. Because the engine also features a variable valve timing system, you'll feel the benefit of that torque across a wider range, making this C3 happier when pulling from a standstill.
It's also a good deal more refined than the 8v unit when extended. You won't even pay a penalty in terms of overall fuel consumption, the 16v engine returning an average of 47.1mpg which is even better than the 8v unit. The 143g/km of carbon dioxide emissions also land this particular C3 in a very low taxation band.
And the Sensodrive gearbox? Well, it does make this C3 supremely easy to pilot in urban traffic. The gearbox features a mode whereby it defaults to a conventional automatic transmission, thus saving you the bother of shifting yourself. When the road opens up, you can switch it to sequential mode and flip up and down the gears using paddles behind the steering wheel or the centrally mounted gear lever. It's not one of those clever clutchless manuals like an Alfa Romeo Selespeed or a Vauxhall Easytronic system - there's still a conventional automatic torque converter - but it does offer three different programs (Normal, Sport & Snow) as well as that fully automatic mode. Also worthy of note is that fact that SensoDrive has been tweaked in the latest facelifted C3 models. It now features revised shifting paddles with a higher-quality feel and a chrome-topped gearlever that slides around its gate rather than centring itself after a mode has been selected.
This version comes only in SX trim, which means you can expect to find luxury items like a CD stereo and digital air-conditioning amongst other things as standard. The car has undergone a bout of cosmetic surgery since it first arrived on the scene and the current car can be distinguished from its forebears by means of its restyled nose with bigger air intake, more pronounced grille and far bigger chromed Citroen chevrons. More important are the alterations inside which include revised and markedly higher-quality dashboard and door panels. The stereo and ventilation controls look tidier and there's a more grown-up feel about the interior generally. The effect is still not class-leading but it's much more like it.
The technology behind 'Stop & Start' is nothing new. Volkswagen dabbled with it twenty years ago. However, this is the first time any manufacturer has seriously brought it to the volume market. You have to wonder what has taken everybody so long - and how long it will be before it's simply something we all take for granted. Up until now, the 1.4-litre 16v petrol model accounted for around 10% of all Citroen's C3 sales. One thing's for certain: that figure's going to rise.
The results below show the top C3 deals on buyacar
|
Citroen C3 1.4i 16V Stop and Start 5dr Sensodrive Hatchback | |||
| ETR | Mthly £185 |
Saving £1,937 |
Price £10,153 |
|
PCP finance quote over 48 months, 10,000 miles pa, deposit of £1000
| For C3 STOP&START 1.4 16v | ||
| Performance | 7 | |
| Comfort | 6 | |
| Handling | 4 | |
| Economy | 8 | |
| Space / Versatility | 8 | |
| Styling | 7 | |
| Equipment | 8 | |
| Build | 4 | |
| Depreciation | 7 | |
| Insurance | 8 | |
| Value | 9 | |
| OVERALL | 6.9 OUT OF 10 | |
C3 models:
Mon to Fri 9am-6pm
Sat 9am-5pm
Sun Closed