Most reliable cars 2019

Japanese and South Korean cars least likely to let you down; there's a Peugeot among the most reliable cars too

Dominic Tobin
Mar 13, 2019

Car reliability surveys tend to confirm what you've always suspected: Japanese cars are virtually bulletproof, Italian cars are lovable but let you down and French models have more than their share of electrical issues.

But not any more. Yes, Japanese models still dominate the most recent table of most reliable cars but there's now a French model in the top ten: the Peugeot 3008 family crossover car (tall like an off-roader but with the driving feel of a hatchback)

It's ranked fifth for reliability in the Auto Expreess Driver Power survey, wich is based on the experience of real drivers. The table is topped by the Japanese Lexus NX and other top performers include Kia, Toyota, Mazda, and Honda have also performed well this year, as expected. But the big French surprise comes courtesy of the Peugeot 3008 crossover, which takes fifth spot.

The Driver Power survey quizzed owners of cars that were less than 12 months old, covering 31 different subject areas like fuel economy, practicality, and reliability, in what is one of the most comprehensive new car surveys out there.

For more information on the reliability of used cars, it's worth looking at the alternative JD Power dependability survey.

The Driver Power poll didn't give the entire French motor industry a resounding bill of health, though. Peugeot's ageing 208 - due to be replaced this year - finished third from bottom, just above the Dacia Sandero and Fiat 500X. If you’re considering one of these lower-ranking cars, then the results shouldn’t mean you immediately strike them off your list: modern cars are extremely reliable, and even the bottom-placed Fiat has a reliability score of 86.35%, which is just 10% behind the best-placed Lexus NX.

Most reliable cars 2019

 

Most reliable cars 2019: in detail

1. Lexus NX (sold from 2015–present)

Reliability score 96.25%

For years, Lexus has shown that it's possible to have a high-tech car that's crammed with gadgets and powered by a complicated hybrid system, but still delivers class-leading reliability.

The car's quality helped to push it to the top of the rankings, as did the relatively low rate of faults. Fewer than 7% of owners reported any sort of problem and braking issues were most common among those that did.

The NX is only available as a petrol or hybrid car. On motorways, the NX seems to glide along, but can feel bumpy at lower speeds. On the upside, it’s a striking-looking car with high levels of standard equipment The interior is roomy, too, although rear headroom is tight, and the boot is on the small side but does have a flat floor when the seats are folded.
Lexus NX buying guide

  

2. Kia Sorento (2014-present)

Reliability score 96.08%

A seven-seat car like the Kia Sorento doesn’t always get an easy life. You might find packed with children on the school run or regularly used as a small van, with the seats folded down. That makes the Sorento’s second place even more impressive.

Although buyers aren’t likely to need it, the Sorento comes with a seven year warranty, limited to 100,000 miles, as with all Kia’s. It’s the longest guarantee in the industry.

Owners are impressed with the quality of this modern Kia, which has been slightly improved in an updated version of the car that went on sale earlier this year. Despite the car's high ranking, the Sorento isn't flawless - almost a quarter of owners mentioned gremlins with electrics.
Kia Sorento buying guide

  

3. Toyota Prius (2015-present)

Reliability score 95.93%

The latest generation of the Toyota Prius isn't just the world's best-known hybrid car, it's also an extremely good family car on its own merit, which shouldn't simply be left to minicab drivers.

The hybrid combines a petrol engine with an electric motor, which can recover energy normally lost during braking. This is re-used to power the car at slow speeds or to provide an extra boost while accelerating. Owners rate the car's impressive fuel econonmy in real-world driving and its low rate of issues: just over 6 percent of owners reported problems and the most common involved paint and exterior trim panels.
Toyota Prius buying guide

 

4. Mazda MX-5 (2015-present)

Reliability score 95.82%

Wildly fun and yet eminently sensible: the light and nimble Mazda MX-5 can dart down country roads like few other cars thanks to its responsive, direct steering and high-revving engine.

And unlike a traditional sports car, you can virtually guarantee that the MX-5 will start on demand and get you to your destination without spluttering to a halt. The car's reliability is exceptionally good, with fewer than ten percent of owners reporting problems - the most common of which were electrical.
Mazda MX-5 buying guide

  

5. Peugeot 3008 (2016-present)

Reliability score 95.22%

Yes, a Peugeot really is one of the most reliable cars in Britain and it's also the most reliable non-Japanese or South Korean car. That's some achievement for the French company which was renowned for poor quality until recently.

The company moved upmarket with the 3008 crossover (combining all the comfort and fuel economy of a hatchback with the higher driving position of a  off-road vehicle), introducing a dual-screen dashboard, striking design and a high-quality interior with soft plastic and cool metal surfaces. It's paid off enormously, with buyers ranking it the very best car to own in Britain.

It didn't quite make it to the top spot in the reliability table, which is partly due to the 11% of owners that reported some kind of problem - most commonly electrical - but the 3008 outperforms all rival family crossovers.
Peugeot 3008 buying guide

  

6. Honda CR-V (2012-present)

Reliability score 95.16%

The Honda CR-V is being replaced with a new model this year but the outgoing version is still upholding the company’s reputation for strong reliability.

Owners liked the Honda's spaciousness and also rated its lack of faults: only one in ten cars had a problem and the most common issue was once again electrics, which might irritating, but isn't always serious.

As the car comes to the end of its life, there are increasingly good deals on new and nearly new models, particularly considering its size and practicality.
Honda CR-V buying guide

  

7. Mazda CX-5 (2017-present)

Reliability score 95.15%

The second Mazda in this list has won praise for the nimble, car-like way that it drives and for its efficiency. The CX-5 is also one of the most reliable cars on the market, with few serious issues (electrics and brakes being the most commomn complaints) and plenty of praise for its high-quality interior.

It's a step up from the excellent CX-5 that it replaced last year, although that car still remains a good used buy.

  

8. Toyota Verso (2009-present)

Reliability score 95.10%

Almost a decade old and still showing younger rivals how it's done, the Toyota Verso might not win any awards for style or technology, but you can certainly depend on it.

Owners like the car's spacious and practical interior -which is available with seven seats - as well as its comfortable ride and low running costs. A small proportion of owners - 14% - experienced issues, with gearbox complaints most common, but they didn't dent its reliability score too much.

  

=9. Skoda Octavia (2013-present)

Reliability score 94.55%

Skoda started off as a Czech company but it's now part of the Volkswagen Group, which makes the Octavia the lone standard-bearer of German engineering in this year's ten most reliable cars list.

Fewer than one in ten owners reported any issues and of those, gearbox problems were the biggest cause of complaint. The quality of the car's interior and its vast interior space far outweighed any downsides, according to owners. The car was updated last year with a new four-headlight design, shown above, and some interior technology improvements. They didn't make much of a difference to the car, though, so any car from the current generation makes a good choice.
Skoda Octavia buying guide

  

=9. Lexus CT (2011-present)

Reliability score 94.55%

Just 5% of owners of Lexus’s compact five-door hatchback reported having a problem with their car, which is among the lowest in this year’s survey.

it’s effectively a more luxurious version of the Toyota Prius (Lexus is Toyota’s premium brand), with the same hybrid technology that brings excellent fuel economy if you’re driving in town.

Aside from reliability, the CT does have some drawbacks. It’s rather old now and it has less interior space than more alternative family hatchbacks. The ride is rather firm, too, and the dashboard, while being well-made, looks fussy and old-fashioned.
Lexus CT buying guide

 

Latest best cars & vans

  1. Best new small cars for towing

  2. Best used cars under £400 per month

  3. Best used car finance deals

What our customers say